1Nightmare Cafeteria Segment
2The gremlin from the bus holding Ned's severed head
3Hybrids on the Island of Dr. Hibbert
4Homer trying to kill his family in "The Shinning"
5Bart's long-lost twin
6Ned Flanders' future utopia in "Time and Punishment"
7Nightmare on Evergreen Terrace Segment
8Mr. Burns' head sewn onto Homer's body
9Goldilocks gets murdered by the three bears in "Scary Tales Can Come True"
10Fog that turns the Simpsons inside out
11Homer runs into the third dimension
12The clown bed scene
15Homer eating himself in "Me-gan"
18Springfield losing a battle with killer dolphins and dying in the sea; Lisa regrets freeing the leader
19Treehouse of Horror II - Homer Simpson: a dream or not?